If you blow through the retainer hours most months, the retainer is too small for what the client actually asks for. Working faster will not fix that. Raise the price, tighten the scope, or both. Here are the three signs, the math, and the words to use.
The retainer that is always empty by the 20th
The client pays for 20 hours a month. By the 20th, you have used 28. You do not charge for the extra eight, because the relationship is good and you do not want to make a thing of it. You tell yourself you will be more efficient next month.
Next month is the same. You are not slow. The retainer is wrong.
Three signs it is the retainer, not you
1. You go over most months
Once is a busy month. Three months out of four is the real size of the work. Look back six months. If you went over in four or more, the number in the contract is fiction.
2. The work has changed since you set the price
You agreed to 20 hours of social posts. Now you also do the newsletter, the occasional landing page, and "quick" design tweaks. The scope grew. The price did not.
3. The "small extras" are not small
Add up the "can you just" requests for one month. If they total more than 10% of the retainer, they are not extras. They are the job.
Do the math
Over the last three months:
- Hours included: 60.
- Hours actually worked: 84.
- Fee received: $6,000.
- Real rate: $6,000 ÷ 84 = $71 an hour, against the $100 you set it at.
You are giving this client a 29% discount they did not ask for and do not know about. The retainer burn calculator shows when the hours will run out at your current pace, and the effective hourly rate calculator shows the real rate.
Working faster is not the answer
Speed has a limit. Good work takes the time it takes. If you squeeze, quality drops, revisions go up, and you lose the time you saved. The honest fixes are about price and scope.
Three honest fixes
- Raise the retainer to the real hours. "Over the last quarter the work has averaged 28 hours a month. I'd like to move the retainer to 28 hours at the same rate."
- Keep the price and tighten the scope. "At 20 hours, the retainer covers the social posts and the newsletter. Landing pages and design tweaks would be quoted separately."
- Both, with a choice. Offer two options and let the client pick. People like choosing.
How to have the conversation
Do it with numbers, in writing, before the renewal.
"I pulled the hours for the last three months. The retainer covers 20 hours a month, and the work has averaged 28, mostly because the newsletter and landing pages were added since we started. I've been covering the difference, and I'd rather be clear about it than quietly stretch. Here are two options: move to 28 hours a month, or keep 20 hours and quote the newsletter and landing pages separately. Which works better for you?"
No apology. No blame. Facts, a reason, two options.
What usually happens
Most clients say yes to one of the options, often with some surprise that you were not already charging for the extra. A few push back. A very few leave. The ones who leave were paying you $71 an hour and would have kept pushing that number down. Letting them go frees 28 hours a month for a client who pays your rate.
Where M-Tracker fits
In M-Tracker, retainer work lives in a project with the hours included, and the timer records the actual hours against it, including the extras. You can see the burn during the month instead of at the end, and the project record is the evidence for the renewal conversation. Finished work is checked against its brief before it goes to the client, which cuts the revision rounds that quietly eat retainers.
Try M-Tracker free14-day trial. No credit card. No employee surveillance.
Work you can trust, without redoing it.
Your team gets feedback before work reaches you, or your client.
Copyright © 2020 – 2026 M-Tracker. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy