Good recruiters pick in three steps, always in the same order. First, must-haves: does this person have what the order says it cannot do without? Second, evidence: can they prove it, with dates and numbers, not just words? Third, fit: will they work on this shift, at this site, with this crew? Must-haves cut the pile. Evidence ranks it. Fit decides between the last few. Done in a different order, the recruiter falls for a great resume for the wrong job.
Step one: must-haves
Take the written order. Pull out the three to five things the client will not hire without. For a warehouse order: current forklift card, agreed to nights, can start Monday, steel-toe boots, pay accepted at $19.
Now the resume is a yes-or-no exercise. Does it show a current card? Does it mention nights? Anything missing is a question for the phone screen, not a reason to guess.
Step two: evidence
For each must-have, look for proof. Here is one resume scored against the order above.
| Must-have | What the resume says | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Current forklift card | "Forklift certified, renewed March 2026" | Proven |
| Nights | "Night shift, cold storage, 2024 to 2026" | Proven |
| Start Monday | "Available immediately" | Confirm by phone |
| Steel-toe boots | Not mentioned | Ask |
| Pay $19 | Last role listed at $18.50 | Likely fine, confirm |
Two proven, three to confirm. That is a phone screen, not a submittal, yet. The screen asks the three questions and the answers go into the submittal as facts.
Step three: fit
With two or three candidates who clear steps one and two, fit decides. Who has done this kind of site before? Who answered the phone the first time? Who said "I haven't done that" when they had not? Fit is about the shift, the crew and the person's habits, not about whether you liked them.
Why the order matters
Start with fit and you pick the friendly candidate with the expired card. Start with evidence and you spend twenty minutes on a resume that fails a must-have in line two. Must-haves, evidence, fit. Every time.
What the submittal should then say
The first three lines of the submittal answer the must-haves with the evidence. "Forklift card renewed March 2026. Two years on nights in cold storage. Confirmed available Monday, boots owned, pay agreed." The client reads it and does not have to check.
Where M-Tracker fits
Steps one and two are a comparison between the order and the candidate. M-Tracker does that comparison on the submittal before the client sees it: the order is the brief, the submittal is the work, and the note says in plain words which must-haves are proven and which are still missing. The recruiter fills the gap before it becomes a rejection.
Try M-Tracker free14-day trial. No credit card. No employee surveillance.
Questions people ask
Do recruiters really read every resume?
Not fully. They read for must-haves first, which takes seconds per resume, and only read fully the ones that pass.
Does a cover letter matter?
For most staffing roles, no. Evidence for the must-haves matters.
How many candidates should go to the client?
Two or three who clear all three steps beat ten who clear one. The client's time is part of the service.
Work you can trust, without redoing it.
Your team gets feedback before work reaches you, or your client.
Copyright © 2020 – 2026 M-Tracker. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy